Crypto Tax season is here. Start planning with our free playbook →
Follow Us

SEC and Cryptocurrency: A Definitive Guide to Regulation and Oversight

Cryptocurrency

Introduction

The emergence of cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin and Ether ushered in a new paradigm of digital assets and blockchain-based financial systems. As crypto has grown into a $3 trillion market, regulatory agencies like the SEC have been playing catch-up in providing oversight and protection for investors.

The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) serves a critical role in regulating securities markets and enforcing rules that protect the investing public and ensure fair dealings. The SEC holds ultimate authority around determining whether a cryptocurrency or token offering constitutes a security, which puts it under their supervision.

So how does the SEC view and approach cryptocurrency regulation today? This definitive guide examines the SEC’s existing crypto authority, key actions and proposals, regulatory gaps yet to be addressed, and outlook for crypto policy and oversight going forward.

SEC Regulatory Authority and Actions Towards Crypto

The SEC operates under three key mandates in its mission:

  1. Protect investors
  2. Maintain fair, orderly, and efficient markets
  3. Facilitate capital formation

Under these guiding principles, the SEC has taken an aggressive stance that many cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin and Ether are securities, rather than currencies, commodities or utilities.

“These so-called crypto-assets—we call them securities at the SEC—meet the Supreme Court’s ‘looks like a duck’ test for investment contracts or notes and must register with the SEC or qualify for an exemption.” – SEC Chairman Gary Gensler

This view has significant implications, as it means existing US securities laws likely apply to most cryptocurrencies:

  • The offer, sale and trading of crypto tokens may require SEC registration as securities transactions
  • Crypto investment vehicles may need to register with SEC as broker-dealers, exchanges, mutual funds, etc.
  • Crypto trading platforms must register as national securities exchanges
  • Promotions of crypto offerings can violate anti-fraud and marketing regulations
  • Strict recordkeeping and financial controls must be in place

While the SEC holds this broad interpretation, they’ve been more definitive in actions against specific cases they deem securities violations:

  • Launching dozens of investigations into Initial Coin Offerings (ICOs) that potentially violated securities laws through illegal token sales
  • Pursuing high profile enforcement cases against XRP, alleging an unregistered $1.3B securities offering
  • Settling charges of securities fraud against cryptocurrency lending platforms like BlockFi
  • Recently rejecting Bitcoin spot ETF application, though approving Bitcoin futures ETFs

At the same time, SEC authority has key limitations within crypto markets:

  • They hold no direct oversight of cryptocurrencies themselves if deemed not to be securities
  • No jurisdiction over decentralized blockchain networks like Bitcoin and Ethereum
  • Unilateral authority concentrated at SEC level, requiring Congressional legislation for expansive new rules

These constraints have led private sector legal experts to criticize the SEC for regulation by enforcement in an environment of regulatory uncertainty.

Cryptocurrency

 

Proposed Crypto Regulations and Legislation

Absent formal rulemaking, new legislation has been proposed to draw brighter lines around regulatory treatment of cryptocurrencies:

Bill Overview Status
Lummis-Gillibrand Responsible Financial Innovation Act Would classify cryptocurrencies into categories like securities, commodities, and sovereign digital currencies, each with tailored regulations Introduced June 2022, awaiting Committee hearings
Stablecoin Tethering and Bank Licensing Enforcement (STABLE) Act Would impose bank licensing requirements on stablecoin issuers to strengthen reserves, disclosures and supervision Introduced July 2022, referred to Senate Committee

Lawmaker statements have also pressed the SEC to escalate crypto assets as a priority issue requiring more resources and staff expertise. In response, the SEC created an internal Crypto Assets and Cyber Unit focused on:

  • Policy recommendations around crypto products and platforms
  • Launching investigations into unregistered crypto asset offerings
  • Pursuing tips, complaints, and referrals on crypto-related misconduct
  • Providing guidance and public awareness notices on crypto compliance

Though lacking legislative powers, the SEC continues wielding its authority to regulate crypto when deemed securities. This leads to ongoing tensions around innovation versus protection.

Outlook for Crypto Regulation and Next Steps

Industry leaders have raised concerns about regulators categorically deeming all cryptocurrencies as securities without tailored policy.

“Blanket regulation of crypto as securities would collapse the innovation in the U.S,” said Jeremy Allaire, CEO of crypto trading platform Circle.

Appropriately regulating cryptocurrency represents an intricate balancing act for the SEC and lawmakers:

Table: Crypto Regulatory Considerations for SEC & Congress

Challenge vs Priority
Encouraging responsible crypto innovation Preventing risky products harming consumers  
Not stifling growth of blockchain networks Curbing crypto market manipulation & fraud  
Allowing access to crypto yield opportunities Safeguarding against systemic risks  
Protecting private keys/wallets as personal property Combating crypto asset crime/terrorist financing  

Industry leaders expect eventual legislation and SEC rules establishing a crypto-specific regulatory framework covering:

  • Definitions of cryptocurrencies, stablecoins, tokenized securities
  • Updated registration, reporting and oversight rules tailored to crypto
  • Governance of crypto trading/lending platforms and exchanges
  • Clarified tax implications

Though consensus supports the need for greater regulatory clarity, this represents a complex task. The intensive SEC scrutiny and expected rulemaking contributes to the sense cryptocurrencies have entered a new phase of maturity. The ultimate regulatory guardrails put in place stand to shape crypto innovation and mainstream adoption for years to come.

Implications for Crypto Investors and Entrepreneurs

In this environment of legal gray area and shifting regulatory sands around crypto, what does it mean for everyday cryptocurrency investors and entrepreneurs?

The following precautions apply until clear frameworks emerge:

For Crypto Investors

  • Carefully assess project teams, whitepapers and capabilities prior to investment
  • Be alert to Ponzi schemes and inadequate disclosures around crypto offerings
  • Avoid investing based on hype, celebrity endorsements or pressure tactics
  • Report suspicious investment opportunities to SEC/CFTC whistleblower programs

For Crypto Entrepreneuers

  • Assume SEC views tokens/coins as securities and register offerings or qualify for exemptions
  • Implement strict controls around custody, trading, recordkeeping and reserves
  • Closely track evolving compliance guidance as legislation develops
  • Seek legal counsel about deploying compliant crypto platforms

Though regulatory uncertainty persists today, expanded SEC authority paired with thoughtful legislation promises to nurture crypto innovation while protecting consumers. As custodians of one of the most sophisticated financial regulatory systems globally, US regulators and lawmakers face high stakes in getting the recipe right.

 

Notable SEC Crypto Enforcement Actions

The SEC has already brought dozens of enforcement cases against cryptocurrency companies to date. Some of the most impactful actions include:

Ripple Lawsuit Over XRP Cryptocurrency

The highest profile action alleges Ripple conducted an unregistered securities sale worth over $1.3 billion. The SEC argues XRP is a security, while Ripple contends it is a currency and utility token. The outcome of this case could set precedent on crypto regulation.

BlockFi Lending Platform Settlement

BlockFi agreed to pay $100 million in penalties to the SEC and state regulators for failing to register a crypto lending product the SEC deemed a security. The action saw BlockFi stop opening new interest accounts.

Crypto Landing Platform Enforcement

The SEC reached multiple settlements with crypto lending platforms like Celsius Network, Voyager Digital, and BlockFi for securities violations over interest-bearing accounts. This signals tighter future oversight of crypto yield products.

10X Capital & Cryptopias.com Scheme

The SEC charged two co-founders with defrauding over 2,000 retail investors out of $7 million across crypto and forex trading platforms using fake testimonials and promises of guaranteed returns.

REcoin & DRC Promoters

Both initial coin offerings were charged with illegally selling unregistered securities after falsely promising tokens backed by real estate and diamonds. The principals were ordered to repay over $9 million collected from investors.

PlexCoin ICO

The PlexCoin ICO promised a 1,354% profit in under 29 days, offering tokens on major exchanges quickly. The SEC found this a blatant scam. Besides securities law violations, PlexCoin’s founder Dominic Lacroix was jailed for contempt.

This snapshot of recent SEC crypto enforcements demonstrates tightening oversight across token issuances, crypto lending, exchanges, ICOs and investment schemes making unsupported promises to investors.

Crypto Regulation Around the Globe

The regulatory landscape differs across the world when it comes to cryptocurrencies. Below is a comparison of cryptoasset rules across major economic powers.

United States

The U.S. uses a case-by-case approach driven by the SEC and CFTC determining whether tokens classify as securities. If not deemed securities, crypto is legal though rules vary by state. Regulatory authority remains split among agencies.

European Union

The EU regulates cryptoassets by monitoring Anti-Money Laundering/Combating the Financing of Terrorism (AML/CFT) rules. The EU defines cryptocurrency more broadly than the U.S. Some members have crypto-specific legislation like Germany.

United Kingdom

The UK treats cryptoassets as tradeable property. Rules require firms like exchanges to register with the Financial Conduct Authority for AML/CFT regulations. Her Majesty’s Treasury has consulted on further DeFi and stablecoin regulations.

China

China has instituted a blanket ban on cryptocurrency trading and mining, although it continues advancing a digital yuan. Regulators aim to contain financial risks from crypto speculation and preserve state control over currencies.

Global Cooperation

The Financial Stability Board (FSB), International Organization of Securities Commissions (IOSCO), and Basel Committee on Banking Supervision (BCBS) are working with one another and the G20 on coordinating global cryptoasset monitoring.

This mixed global landscape results in widely varying investor protections, operational rules, and barriers to crypto innovation across jurisdictions. As cryptocurrencies grow more intertwined with traditional finance, regulators everywhere confront questions about fashioning improved governance.

Conclusion

As key regulators like the SEC continue intensifying their oversight of cryptocurrencies when deemed securities, expectations point to eventual concrete federal legislation and formal rulemaking. This promises to both nurture innovation by codifying specific regulations, while also prioritizing consumer safeguards.

In navigating current gray areas in law and reporting suspicious activity, investors and entrepreneurs play a crucial role in advocating for judicious crypto governance themselves.

Collaborative public-private partnerships toward tailored crypto regulatory frameworks can help balance these objectives successfully. The advent of cryptocurrency and blockchain technology has unlocked invaluable potential around access, efficiency and transparency in finance.

With diligent cooperation between regulators, lawmakers and industry leaders, we can capitalize on this promise while evolving oversight to new realities of digital finance. Prioritizing the protection of consumers without limiting responsible innovation remains paramount as crypto regulation develops in the coming years.

 

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Get updates and learn from the best

Share this story

More To Explore